BVA responds to Defra decision on controlled shooting in pilot badger culls
Responding to comments by Defra Minister George Eustice that the badger cull pilots in Somerset and Gloucestershire will be completed using both controlled shooting and cage trapping and shooting
BVA President John Blackwell said:
“We are disappointed that the Government has taken the decision to continue using controlled shooting in the pilots given that the first two years of culling failed to demonstrate conclusively that controlled shooting could be carried out effectively or humanely based on the criteria that were set.
“The Government’s rationale for the continued use of controlled shooting is based on a comparison with the control of other wildlife, but these are not the parameters that the Government set itself at the start of the pilots. Instead – at the behest of BVA and others – the Government asked an independent group of experts to oversee the pilots and the Independent Expert Panel set out criteria which were used to assess humaneness.
“BVA remains fully in support of a comprehensive strategy to tackle bovine TB, including the use of targeted, humane badger culling alongside a range of other measures. However, culling should only be carried out using the tried and tested method of cage trapping and shooting.
“It is difficult to argue that the use of controlled shooting for badger culling is ethical when another more humane and effective method is available. We therefore continue to urge Defra to complete the pilots using cage trapping and shooting only and to roll out badger culling to other areas using this method.”
On the comments by BVA’s specialist divisions in support of the continued use of controlled shooting, Mr Blackwell added:
“The BVA’s decision to withdraw our support for the use of controlled shooting as part of the badger culling policy was taken by our Council following consultation with our expert committees, our specialist divisions and our wider membership. We recognise that, like the general population, our members hold a wide range of views and for some our position doesn’t go far enough, while for others it goes too far.
“BVA called for an independent expert panel (IEP) to assess the use of controlled shooting and called on Defra to implement the IEP’s recommendations in full. When the second year of culling failed to demonstrate conclusively that controlled shooting could be carried out effectively and humanely based on the criteria set by the IEP, the only credible option for BVA was to withdraw support for controlled shooting in light of the evidence.
“Our position is therefore wholly appropriate and consistent with our previous statements on badger culling, taking into account the available evidence and the wide range of views expressed by our members.”
